Post by BiteUrLip on Jan 14, 2018 8:56:06 GMT
This is my review for this huge collection of CD's.
I'm giving points for the pieces, and total value comes from the amount of points for the cd. Average value means the average quality of a piece on the cd.
CD 1: Gregorian Chant - Feast Of Stephen / Marchaut: Chansons
Total value: 40,5 (Low)
Average value: 4,05 (Low)
No highlights or super highlights.
No disasters.
CD 2: Dufay / Josquin Des Pres: Motets
Total value: 48 (Low)
Average value: 4,36 (Low)
No highlights or super highlights.
No disasters.
CD 3: Wind Music From Renaissance Italy
Total value: 109,5 (Moderate)
Average value: 3,91 (Low)
No highlights or super highlights.
No disasters.
CD 4: Tallis: Spem in alium / Byrd: Mass For Three Voices / De Victoria: Gardanum / Palestrina: Missa Papae Marcelli / Allegri: Miserere
Total value: 106 (Moderate)
Average value: 7,54 (Moderate)
Highlights: "Missa Papae Marcelli -Kyrie"
No super highlights.
No disasters.
CD 5: Monteverdi: Vespers (Highlights), Madrigals
Total value: 76,5 (Low)
Average value: 3,64 (Low)
No highlights or super highlights.
No disasters.
CD 6: Schütz / Buxtehude / Pachelbel: Chamber Music
Total value: 237,5 (High)
Average value: 10,33 (Moderate)
Highlights: "Partie (Suite) In G Major -Sonatina", "Partie (Suite) In E Minor-Sonata. Adagio - Aria", "Canon And Gigue In D Major-1. Canon (Excerpt)"
No super highlights.
No disasters.
CD 7: Purcell: Dido And Aeneas (Highlights); The Fairy Queen (Highlights), Te Deum And Jubilate
Total value: 120 (Moderate)
Average value: 7,06 (Moderate)
No highlights or super highlights.
No disasters.
CD 8: Charpentier: Te Deum / Rameau: Une Symphonie Imaginaire
Total value: 408 (High)
Average value: 15,11 (High)
The first cd to include a super highlight... which is nowadays used as the theme music for Eurovision. So:
Highlights: "Te Deum For Soloists, Chorus And Orchestra, H 146 (Marc-Antoine Charpentier)-Te aeternum Patrem (Chorus, Soprano I/II, Mezzo-Soprano, Tenor)", "Te Deum For Soloists, Chorus And Orchestra, H 146 (Marc-Antoine Charpentier)-Tu devicto mortis aculeo (Chorus, Bass)", "Te Deum For Soloists, Chorus And Orchestra, H 146 (Marc-Antoine Charpentier)-In te, Domine, speravi (Chorus, Mezzo-Soprano, Tenor, Bass)", "Zaïs (Jean-Philippe Rameau)-Overture (Live At Theatre, Salle Molière, Poissy / 2003)", "Les Boréades / Act 4-Gavottes pour les Heures et les Zéphirs (Live At Theatre, Salle Molière, Poissy / 2003)"
Super highlights: "Te Deum For Soloists, Chorus And Orchestra, H 146 (Marc-Antoine Charpentier)-Prélude . Rondeau"
No disasters.
CD 9: Telemann: Concertos
Total value: 207,5 (Moderate)
Average value: 8,64 (Moderate)
Highlights: "Concerto In A Major For Two Violins In Scordatura And Continuo (Georg Philipp Telemann)-4. Bourrée", "Sonata (Concerto) In C Major For 4 Violins Without Basso Continuo-4. Allegro"
No super highlights.
No disasters.
CD 10: Vivaldi: The Four Seasons R.269, R.315, R.293, R.297; Gloria In D Major R. 589
Total value: 613 (Very high)
Average value: 25,54 (Very high)
Highlights: "Concerto For Violin And Strings In E, Op.8, No.1, R.269 "La Primavera" (Antonio Vivaldi)-3. Allegro (Danza pastorale)", "Concerto For Violin And Strings In G Minor, Op.8, No.2, R.315 "L'estate"-3. Presto (Tempo impetuoso d'estate)", "Concerto For Violin And Strings In F, Op.8, No.3, R.293 "L'autunno"-3. Allegro (La caccia)", "Gloria In D, R.589 - G.Ricordi 1970, Ed. Malipiero-3. Laudamus te", "Gloria In D, R.589 - G.Ricordi 1970, Ed. Malipiero-7. Domine Fili Unigenite", "Gloria In D, R.589 - G.Ricordi 1970, Ed. Malipiero-11. Quoniam tu solus Sanctus"
Super highlights: "Concerto For Violin And Strings In E, Op.8, No.1, R.269 "La Primavera" (Antonio Vivaldi)-1. Allegro", "Concerto For Violin And Strings In F Minor, Op.8, No.4, R.297 "L'inverno"-2. Largo"
CD 11: Bach, J.S.: Brandenburg Concertos No.2 In F, BWV 1047 & No.5 In D, BWV 1050; Suite No.2 In B Minor, BWV 1067
Total value: 278 (High)
Average value: 21,38 (Very high)
Highlights: "Suite No.2 In B Minor, BWV 1067-2. Rondeau"
Super highlights: "Brandenburg Concerto No.2 In F, BWV 1047 (Johann Sebastian Bach)-1. (Allegro)", "Suite No.2 In B Minor, BWV 1067-7. Badinerie"
CD 12: Bach, J.S.: Goldberg Variations, BWV 988; Fantasia In C Minor, BWV 906; Italian Concerrto In F, BWV 971; Fantasia And Fugue In A Minor, BWV 904
Total value: 223 (Moderate)
Average value: 5,87 (Low)
CD 13: Bach, J.S.: Organ Works
Total value: 72 (Low)
Average value: 5,54 (Low)
CD 14: Bach, J.S.: St. Matthew Passion - Highlights
Total value: 121 (Low)
Average value: 7,56 (Low)
Highlights: "St. Matthew Passion, BWV 244 / Part Two-No.42 Aria (Bass): "Gebt mir meinen Jesum wieder""
CD 15: Bach, J.S.: Magnificat, BWV 243; Cantatas BWV 63 & 65
Total value: 286 (High)
Average value: 11,44 (Moderate)
CD 16: Handel: Music For The Royal Fireworks, HWV 351; Concerto grosso In C, HWV 318; Arrival Of The Queen Of Sheba, HWV 67; Belshazzar - Overture, HWV 61, Sinfonia HWV 53 & 57
Total value: 421,5 (High)
Average value: 21,08 (Very high)
Highlights: "Music For The Royal Fireworks:
Suite HWV 351 (Georg Friedrich Händel)-3. La paix
Music For The Royal Fireworks: Suite HWV 351 (Georg Friedrich Händel)-4. La réjouissance
Music For The Royal Fireworks: Suite HWV 351 (Georg Friedrich Händel)-6. Menuet II
Concerto grosso In C, HWV 318 "Alexander's Feast"-3. Allegro - Adagio
Belshazzar, HWV 61-Overture
Alceste, HWV 45 / Act 1: Grand Entrée-Maestoso
From Samson (Act I): Sinfonia, HWV 57-2. Allegro
Super highlights:
Solomon, HWV 67-Arrival Of The Queen Of Sheba
No disasters.
CD 17: Handel: Harp Concerto, Op. 4 No.6 In B Flat, HWV 294; Organ Concerto In F No.13, HWV 295 "The Cuckoo And The Nightingale"; Concerto No.3 In G Minor, HWV 287; Concerto a due cori No.2 In F, HWV 333
Total value: 316 (High)
Average value: 18,59 (High)
Highlights:
Organ Concerto No.6 In B Flat, Op.4 No.6 HWV 294 - Version For Harp-1. Andante Allegro
Organ Concerto No.6 In B Flat, Op.4 No.6 HWV 294 - Version For Harp-2. Larghetto
Organ Concerto No.6 In B Flat, Op.4 No.6 HWV 294 - Version For Harp-3. Allegro moderato
Organ Concerto No.13 In F -"Cuckoo And The Nightingale" HWV 295-Larghetto
Organ Concerto No.13 In F -"Cuckoo And The Nightingale" HWV 295-Allegro
Oboe Concerto No.3 In G Minor, HWV 287-2. Allegro
Oboe Concerto No.3 In G Minor, HWV 287-3. Sarabande (Largo)
Concerto a due cori No.2, HWV 333-2. Allegro
Concerto a due cori No.2, HWV 333-5. Allegro ma non troppo - Adagio
Concerto a due cori No.2, HWV 333-6. A tempo ordinario
No super higlights.
No disasters.
CD 18: Handel: Messiah - Arias And Choruses
Total value: 413 (Very high)
Average value: 19,67 (Very high)
Highlights:
Messiah / Part 1-2. Air: "Ev'ry Valley shall be exalted"
Messiah / Part 1-3. Chorus: "And The Glory Of The Lord"
Messiah / Part 1-6. Chorus: "And He shall purify the sons of Levi"
Messiah / Part 1-13. Pifa (Pastoral Symphony)
Messiah / Part 2-24. Chorus: "All we like sheep have gone astray"
Messiah / Part 2-38. Air: "Why do the nations so furiously rage together?"
Messiah / Part 3-51. Chorus: "Worthy is the Lamb... Amen"
Super highlights:
Messiah / Part 2-"Hallelujah"
No disasters.
CD 19: Scarlatti, D: Sonatas
Total value: 303 (High)
Average value: 21,64 (Very high)
Highlights:
D. Scarlatti: Sonata In C Major, K.502
D. Scarlatti: Sonata In C, K.460
D. Scarlatti: Sonata In C, K.461
D. Scarlatti: Sonata In D Minor, K.517
D. Scarlatti: Sonata In D Major, K.479
D. Scarlatti: Sonata In F Major, K.518
D. Scarlatti: Sonata In B Flat Major, K.544
No super highlights.
No disasters.
CD 20: Bach, C.P.E.: Symphonies For Strings, Wq 182 No.1-6 / Bach, J.C.: Quintet In D Major Op.11 No.6
Total value: 349 (High)
Average value: 16,62 (High)
Highlights:
Sinfonia In G, Wq 182 No.1 (Carl Philipp Emanuel Bach)-1. Allegro di molto
Sinfonia In B Flat, Wq 182 No.2-3. Presto
Sinfonia In B Minor Wq 182 No.5-2. Larghetto
Sinfonia In E Major Wq 182 No.6-1. Allegro di molto
Quintet In D For Flute,Oboe,Violin,Viola & Continuo, Op.11, No.6 (Johann Christian Bach)-1. Allegro
Quintet In D For Flute,Oboe,Violin,Viola & Continuo, Op.11, No.6 (Johann Christian Bach)-2. Andantino
Quintet In D For Flute,Oboe,Violin,Viola & Continuo, Op.11, No.6 (Johann Christian Bach)-3. Allegro assai
No super highlights.
No disasters.
I'm giving points for the pieces, and total value comes from the amount of points for the cd. Average value means the average quality of a piece on the cd.
CD 1: Gregorian Chant - Feast Of Stephen / Marchaut: Chansons
Total value: 40,5 (Low)
Average value: 4,05 (Low)
No highlights or super highlights.
No disasters.
CD 2: Dufay / Josquin Des Pres: Motets
Total value: 48 (Low)
Average value: 4,36 (Low)
No highlights or super highlights.
No disasters.
CD 3: Wind Music From Renaissance Italy
Total value: 109,5 (Moderate)
Average value: 3,91 (Low)
No highlights or super highlights.
No disasters.
CD 4: Tallis: Spem in alium / Byrd: Mass For Three Voices / De Victoria: Gardanum / Palestrina: Missa Papae Marcelli / Allegri: Miserere
Total value: 106 (Moderate)
Average value: 7,54 (Moderate)
Highlights: "Missa Papae Marcelli -Kyrie"
No super highlights.
No disasters.
CD 5: Monteverdi: Vespers (Highlights), Madrigals
Total value: 76,5 (Low)
Average value: 3,64 (Low)
No highlights or super highlights.
No disasters.
CD 6: Schütz / Buxtehude / Pachelbel: Chamber Music
Total value: 237,5 (High)
Average value: 10,33 (Moderate)
Highlights: "Partie (Suite) In G Major -Sonatina", "Partie (Suite) In E Minor-Sonata. Adagio - Aria", "Canon And Gigue In D Major-1. Canon (Excerpt)"
No super highlights.
No disasters.
CD 7: Purcell: Dido And Aeneas (Highlights); The Fairy Queen (Highlights), Te Deum And Jubilate
Total value: 120 (Moderate)
Average value: 7,06 (Moderate)
No highlights or super highlights.
No disasters.
CD 8: Charpentier: Te Deum / Rameau: Une Symphonie Imaginaire
Total value: 408 (High)
Average value: 15,11 (High)
The first cd to include a super highlight... which is nowadays used as the theme music for Eurovision. So:
Highlights: "Te Deum For Soloists, Chorus And Orchestra, H 146 (Marc-Antoine Charpentier)-Te aeternum Patrem (Chorus, Soprano I/II, Mezzo-Soprano, Tenor)", "Te Deum For Soloists, Chorus And Orchestra, H 146 (Marc-Antoine Charpentier)-Tu devicto mortis aculeo (Chorus, Bass)", "Te Deum For Soloists, Chorus And Orchestra, H 146 (Marc-Antoine Charpentier)-In te, Domine, speravi (Chorus, Mezzo-Soprano, Tenor, Bass)", "Zaïs (Jean-Philippe Rameau)-Overture (Live At Theatre, Salle Molière, Poissy / 2003)", "Les Boréades / Act 4-Gavottes pour les Heures et les Zéphirs (Live At Theatre, Salle Molière, Poissy / 2003)"
Super highlights: "Te Deum For Soloists, Chorus And Orchestra, H 146 (Marc-Antoine Charpentier)-Prélude . Rondeau"
No disasters.
CD 9: Telemann: Concertos
Total value: 207,5 (Moderate)
Average value: 8,64 (Moderate)
Highlights: "Concerto In A Major For Two Violins In Scordatura And Continuo (Georg Philipp Telemann)-4. Bourrée", "Sonata (Concerto) In C Major For 4 Violins Without Basso Continuo-4. Allegro"
No super highlights.
No disasters.
CD 10: Vivaldi: The Four Seasons R.269, R.315, R.293, R.297; Gloria In D Major R. 589
Total value: 613 (Very high)
Average value: 25,54 (Very high)
Highlights: "Concerto For Violin And Strings In E, Op.8, No.1, R.269 "La Primavera" (Antonio Vivaldi)-3. Allegro (Danza pastorale)", "Concerto For Violin And Strings In G Minor, Op.8, No.2, R.315 "L'estate"-3. Presto (Tempo impetuoso d'estate)", "Concerto For Violin And Strings In F, Op.8, No.3, R.293 "L'autunno"-3. Allegro (La caccia)", "Gloria In D, R.589 - G.Ricordi 1970, Ed. Malipiero-3. Laudamus te", "Gloria In D, R.589 - G.Ricordi 1970, Ed. Malipiero-7. Domine Fili Unigenite", "Gloria In D, R.589 - G.Ricordi 1970, Ed. Malipiero-11. Quoniam tu solus Sanctus"
Super highlights: "Concerto For Violin And Strings In E, Op.8, No.1, R.269 "La Primavera" (Antonio Vivaldi)-1. Allegro", "Concerto For Violin And Strings In F Minor, Op.8, No.4, R.297 "L'inverno"-2. Largo"
CD 11: Bach, J.S.: Brandenburg Concertos No.2 In F, BWV 1047 & No.5 In D, BWV 1050; Suite No.2 In B Minor, BWV 1067
Total value: 278 (High)
Average value: 21,38 (Very high)
Highlights: "Suite No.2 In B Minor, BWV 1067-2. Rondeau"
Super highlights: "Brandenburg Concerto No.2 In F, BWV 1047 (Johann Sebastian Bach)-1. (Allegro)", "Suite No.2 In B Minor, BWV 1067-7. Badinerie"
CD 12: Bach, J.S.: Goldberg Variations, BWV 988; Fantasia In C Minor, BWV 906; Italian Concerrto In F, BWV 971; Fantasia And Fugue In A Minor, BWV 904
Total value: 223 (Moderate)
Average value: 5,87 (Low)
CD 13: Bach, J.S.: Organ Works
Total value: 72 (Low)
Average value: 5,54 (Low)
CD 14: Bach, J.S.: St. Matthew Passion - Highlights
Total value: 121 (Low)
Average value: 7,56 (Low)
Highlights: "St. Matthew Passion, BWV 244 / Part Two-No.42 Aria (Bass): "Gebt mir meinen Jesum wieder""
CD 15: Bach, J.S.: Magnificat, BWV 243; Cantatas BWV 63 & 65
Total value: 286 (High)
Average value: 11,44 (Moderate)
CD 16: Handel: Music For The Royal Fireworks, HWV 351; Concerto grosso In C, HWV 318; Arrival Of The Queen Of Sheba, HWV 67; Belshazzar - Overture, HWV 61, Sinfonia HWV 53 & 57
Total value: 421,5 (High)
Average value: 21,08 (Very high)
Highlights: "Music For The Royal Fireworks:
Suite HWV 351 (Georg Friedrich Händel)-3. La paix
Music For The Royal Fireworks: Suite HWV 351 (Georg Friedrich Händel)-4. La réjouissance
Music For The Royal Fireworks: Suite HWV 351 (Georg Friedrich Händel)-6. Menuet II
Concerto grosso In C, HWV 318 "Alexander's Feast"-3. Allegro - Adagio
Belshazzar, HWV 61-Overture
Alceste, HWV 45 / Act 1: Grand Entrée-Maestoso
From Samson (Act I): Sinfonia, HWV 57-2. Allegro
Super highlights:
Solomon, HWV 67-Arrival Of The Queen Of Sheba
No disasters.
CD 17: Handel: Harp Concerto, Op. 4 No.6 In B Flat, HWV 294; Organ Concerto In F No.13, HWV 295 "The Cuckoo And The Nightingale"; Concerto No.3 In G Minor, HWV 287; Concerto a due cori No.2 In F, HWV 333
Total value: 316 (High)
Average value: 18,59 (High)
Highlights:
Organ Concerto No.6 In B Flat, Op.4 No.6 HWV 294 - Version For Harp-1. Andante Allegro
Organ Concerto No.6 In B Flat, Op.4 No.6 HWV 294 - Version For Harp-2. Larghetto
Organ Concerto No.6 In B Flat, Op.4 No.6 HWV 294 - Version For Harp-3. Allegro moderato
Organ Concerto No.13 In F -"Cuckoo And The Nightingale" HWV 295-Larghetto
Organ Concerto No.13 In F -"Cuckoo And The Nightingale" HWV 295-Allegro
Oboe Concerto No.3 In G Minor, HWV 287-2. Allegro
Oboe Concerto No.3 In G Minor, HWV 287-3. Sarabande (Largo)
Concerto a due cori No.2, HWV 333-2. Allegro
Concerto a due cori No.2, HWV 333-5. Allegro ma non troppo - Adagio
Concerto a due cori No.2, HWV 333-6. A tempo ordinario
No super higlights.
No disasters.
CD 18: Handel: Messiah - Arias And Choruses
Total value: 413 (Very high)
Average value: 19,67 (Very high)
Highlights:
Messiah / Part 1-2. Air: "Ev'ry Valley shall be exalted"
Messiah / Part 1-3. Chorus: "And The Glory Of The Lord"
Messiah / Part 1-6. Chorus: "And He shall purify the sons of Levi"
Messiah / Part 1-13. Pifa (Pastoral Symphony)
Messiah / Part 2-24. Chorus: "All we like sheep have gone astray"
Messiah / Part 2-38. Air: "Why do the nations so furiously rage together?"
Messiah / Part 3-51. Chorus: "Worthy is the Lamb... Amen"
Super highlights:
Messiah / Part 2-"Hallelujah"
No disasters.
CD 19: Scarlatti, D: Sonatas
Total value: 303 (High)
Average value: 21,64 (Very high)
Highlights:
D. Scarlatti: Sonata In C Major, K.502
D. Scarlatti: Sonata In C, K.460
D. Scarlatti: Sonata In C, K.461
D. Scarlatti: Sonata In D Minor, K.517
D. Scarlatti: Sonata In D Major, K.479
D. Scarlatti: Sonata In F Major, K.518
D. Scarlatti: Sonata In B Flat Major, K.544
No super highlights.
No disasters.
CD 20: Bach, C.P.E.: Symphonies For Strings, Wq 182 No.1-6 / Bach, J.C.: Quintet In D Major Op.11 No.6
Total value: 349 (High)
Average value: 16,62 (High)
Highlights:
Sinfonia In G, Wq 182 No.1 (Carl Philipp Emanuel Bach)-1. Allegro di molto
Sinfonia In B Flat, Wq 182 No.2-3. Presto
Sinfonia In B Minor Wq 182 No.5-2. Larghetto
Sinfonia In E Major Wq 182 No.6-1. Allegro di molto
Quintet In D For Flute,Oboe,Violin,Viola & Continuo, Op.11, No.6 (Johann Christian Bach)-1. Allegro
Quintet In D For Flute,Oboe,Violin,Viola & Continuo, Op.11, No.6 (Johann Christian Bach)-2. Andantino
Quintet In D For Flute,Oboe,Violin,Viola & Continuo, Op.11, No.6 (Johann Christian Bach)-3. Allegro assai
No super highlights.
No disasters.